A sign of hope for accountability emerged this month after two Myanmar soldiers finally admitted their crimes.

A perimeter fence is constructed around what is officially known as a vocational skills education center in Xinjiang Uighur Autonomous Region, China, on Sept. 4, 2018.Thomas Peter / Reuters fileSept. 17, 2020, 12:34 PM PDT
By Rayhan Asat, president of the American Turkic Lawyers Association
Over the past several years, the Chinese government has locked up more than a million Uighurs, including model citizens like my 34-year-old brother Ekpar Asat.
A philanthropist and founder of a social media platform catering to the Uighur community known as Bagdax, he came to the United States in 2016 to participate in an exchange program sponsored by the State Department, one from which many world leaders and Chinese citizens of the majority Han ethnicity have benefited for decades. Within weeks of returning from the United States to Xinjiang in western China, he disappeared into the shadows of the internment camps.
Rayhan Asat in front of her brother Ekpar Asat's portrait in September.Courtesy Rahhan Asat
| | China coerces Uyghur women into unwanted marriages | ShareAmericaIn China's Xinjiang province, many Uyghur women face an impossible choice: marry a Han Chinese man or face impri... |
|
|
| | China cuts Uighur births with IUDs, abortion, sterilizationThe Chinese government is taking draconian measures to slash birth rates among Uighurs and other minorities as p... |
|
|
|  | In China’s Crackdown on Muslims, Children Have Not Been SparedIn Xinjiang the authorities have separated nearly half a million children from their families, aiming to instill... |
|
|
| | China treats Uighur kids as 'orphans' after parents seizedISTANBUL (AP) — Every morning, Meripet wakes up to her nightmare: The Chinese government has turned four of her ... |
|
|
After years of this unconscionable treatment, a sign of hope for accountability emerged this month, somewhat ironically in the form of revelations of atrocities committed against another ethnic Muslim minority in Asia, the Rohingya of Myanmar.Last week two Myanmar soldiers, Pvts. Zaw Naing Tun and Myo Win Tun, were shown on video confessing to carrying out orders to “shoot all that you see and all that you hear” against the Rohingya during a 2017 “clearance operation” — a well-orchestrated, systematic attack that forced hundreds of thousands of Rohingya to flee to neighboring Bangladesh.
|  | Thousands in western Myanmar flee as army plans operations, monitors sayReuters Staff Thousands of villagers have fled their homes in Myanmar’s Rakhine state after a local administrator warned dozen... |
|
|
|  | Myanmar soldiers confess to Rohingya massacre: 'Shoot all that you see'The testimony marks the first time members of Myanmar’s military have admitted to what the U.N. and internationa... |
|
|
Rohingya refugees after crossing from Myanmar into Bangladesh, on Nov. 2, 2017.Hannah Mckay / Reuters file
|  | ‘Kill All You See’: In a First, Myanmar Soldiers Tell of Rohingya SlaughterVideo testimony from two soldiers supports widespread accusations that Myanmar’s military tried to eradicate the... |
|
|
It also bolstered the criminal investigations against Myanmar aggressors at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, which investigates individuals suspected of crimes against humanity, genocide and war crimes. At present, the ICC is examining whether Myanmar’s military leaders carried out forced deportations by coercing Rohingya to flee to Bangladesh, an ICC member state.
|  | ICC Says It Can Rule On Alleged Crimes Against the RohingyaThe ruling opens the possibility for the Myanmar military to be held accountable |
|
|
Related
Like China, Myanmar refused to join the ICC, and the court’s jurisdiction principally applies only to those who are member states. However, the Court broadened its jurisdictional reach against Myanmar under a novel legal strategy that Rohingyas are victims of a forced deportation in which the crime was completed in the territory of an ICC member state, Bangladesh. This legal approach could be used in a similar way against China.
| | ICC judges authorise opening of an investigation into the situation in B...On 14 November 2019, Pre-Trial Chamber III of the International Criminal Court ("ICC" or the "Court") authorised... |
|
|
Authoritarian governments often emulate one another; one can find many similar practices between Myanmar and China. Both governments target and persecute ethnic minorities that do not conform to their artificial ideals. Both vehemently deny the allegations while deploying similar strategies and forms of punishment. Both authorities label their genocidal campaigns internal security matters and reject public criticism from democratic countries. Both governments have justified their actions by claiming that the ethnic minorities are extremists, legitimizing ruthless human rights violations under the guise of counterterrorism.
| | Understanding China’s ‘preventive repression’ in XinjiangSheena Chestnut Greitens, Myunghee Lee, and Emir Yazici Sheena Chestnut Greitens, Myunghee Lee, and Emir Yazici explain the timing of China’s crackdown on Uighurs and o... |
|
|
|  | Myanmar general blames crisis on RohingyaThe army chief insists that Rohingya people, who are fleeing violence, have no roots in the country. |
|
|
| | World Report 2019: Rights Trends in MyanmarMyanmar security forces continued to commit grave abuses against Rohingya Muslims throughout 2018, deepening the... |
|
|
|  | Who are the Uighurs?China has been accused by the UK of "gross" human rights abuses against the Muslim minority group. |
|
|
|  | The Long Arm of ChinaRebiya Kadeer Rabiya Kadeer writes in The Wall Street Journal that Beijing is using its growing clout to persecute Uighurs out... |
|
|
|  | Uighurs accuse China of mass detention, torture in landmark complaintIt is the first time members of the minority group have sought to use international law to hold Beijing accounta... |
|
|
The ICC is one of the limited avenues for the Uighur people to pursue accountability in their ongoing struggle for justice because of China’s immense political and economic clout. While the Myanmar crisis benefited from public condemnation by Hollywood celebrities such as Cate Blanchett and Angelina Jolie, China’s overwhelming economic influence has resulted in devastating indifference and complicity from the entertainment industry.
Recommended
This is why the ICC offers so much promise, especially because — since the forcible transfer originated in ICC member states — the ICC could prosecute all the resulting crimes that took place in Xinjiang and other parts of China after the forced deportations. These include torture, enslavement, arbitrary imprisonment, enforced sterilization, enforced disappearances and even genocide.
An active ICC investigation would allow the court to compile a list of names of perpetrators engaged in the atrocities, including those responsible for providing China with the sophisticated technology to create and sustain a police state and develop the internment camps. Once it gathers enough credible information on perpetrators, the court can issue arrest warrants, allowing senior-level perpetrators to be detained whenever they enter any of the 123 ICC member states’ territory.
Additionally, the confession of the two Myanmar soldiers demonstrates the important role of whistleblowers in ICC investigations, whereby lower-level agents can provide key information for identifying senior-level perpetrators against whom the court can eventually issue arrest warrants.
Related
A successful finding of genocide and crimes against humanity in the Myanmar case would send a message that perpetrators cannot commit the crime of all crimes with impunity and bring some sense of justice to Rohinga victims. It would also be a heartening signal to the Uighur community that the ICC is willing to hold economically and politically powerful nonmember state parties accountable for atrocities committed in part on state parties’ territories and bring some form of comfort to victims in their pursuit of justice.
Newly revealed evidence demonstrates that the Chinese government is determined to build new more permanent internment facilities, making it that more urgent for the ICC to launch an investigation to help the innocent victims of internment camps like my brother Ekpar. The Uighur case represents a true test of the international community’s commitment to justice and accountability, and the ICC must seize this opportunity to affirm that no government or official may commit atrocities with impunity.
Rayhan Asat is a lawyer at a Wall Street law firm and serves as president of the American Turkic Lawyers Association (ATILA). She is also a senior fellow at the Raoul Wallenberg Center for Human Rights and chair of the Women Entrepreneurs Committee at Harvard Alumni Entrepreneurs D.C. Chapter.
No comments:
Post a Comment