Ram Puniyani
This year 2023, 14th
April saw plethora of organizations celebrating Baba Saheb Ambedkars 132nd
birth anniversary probably more than before. The occasion was marked by gaiety
and celebratory spirit among the large sections of SC/ST/OBC sections for whom
he is the messiah. His contributions are recognized more and more, not only
nationally but even at global level with over 150 countries celebrating the
occasion. Most groups who are committed to social justice and equality, opposed
to birth based hierarchies and injustices celebrate the occasion with deep
reverence and hope. One can say that this occasion is also assuming religious
overtones as at places rituals are being given more importance than
highlighting Babasaheb’s values. Surely there is a need to launch and sustain
struggles to fulfill the dreams for which Babsaheb struggled all his life.
There are other groups
and formations who are deeply opposed to the principles and values for which
Ambedkar struggled all his life. As such ‘Hindu nationalists’, RSS and progeny,
are totally opposed to Babasaheb’s core aim of ‘annihilation of caste’. They
project ‘harmony among castes’ as their credo. Ambedkar stood for affirmative
action for the deprived sections of society. Initially there were provisions
for reservations for ten years only. Probably Ambedkar had a hope that ten
years will be enough to root out the deep malice of Hindu society. He probably
did not take into consideration the fact that the implementation of the policy
lays in the hands of upper caste elite themselves, who in due course found ways
to circumvent the proper implementation of reservation for SC/STs and so it had
to be prolonged till the date, which is a requisite for march towards social
justice.
The constitution, the
drafting of which he presided over, did give the provision for SCs and STs,
still leaving out Other Backward Classes. This is a large constituent of the
society, about which not much attention was paid for long time. Last time the
decadal census which took this into consideration was in 1931. It stood at 52%
at that time which later became the basis of giving them 27% of reservations in
1990s. There were some provisions for affirmative action but its proper
implementation took place with Mandal Commission implementation only.
The reservations have
been an eyesore to certain sections of society and they did float groups like
“Youth for Equality” types which stood for abolition of reservations. By word
of mouth and other channels it was popularized that due to these reservations,
‘non deserving’ people find their way and the deserving one’s are left out.
Social biases got constructed around dalit-OBCs and these social biases did get
converted in to the suicides of the likes of Rohith Vemula or Darshan Solanki.
These biases also formed the base of anti dalit violence in 1980s in Ahmadabad
and anti OBC violence in Gujarat in 1985.
While BJP’s parent
RSS, initiated social engineering and floated organizations like ‘Samajik
Samrasta Manch’ (Social Harmony Forum) which was an attempt to co-opt these
marginalized sections. Its efforts did pay it rich electoral dividends, which
are reflected in the presence of large number of BJP MPs and MLAs from the
constituencies reserved for these sections. The large force of RSS pracharaks
and Swayamsevaks has relentlessly worked in these areas through social
engineering, process of sanskritzation, and charity work among these
communities.
At ideological level
‘Hindu right wing’ has made tall efforts to attribute ills of caste system to
‘invading’ Muslim kings and trying to project that all castes were equal before
Muslim kings came, type of formulations. It is no surprise that BJP and its
associates also make the show of celebrating Ambedkar anniversary. At the same
time they undermine the need for demands like caste census which can pave the
way for modification of policies, through which the marginalized sections can
benefit in the real sense.
It is this background
that Rahul Gandhi’s speech in Kolar becomes significant. Mr. Gandhi asked for
population census and stated that the results of affirmative action are not as
visible as in the case of top bureaucrats like Secretaries in Union Government,
hardly 7% belong to these sections. While putting forward this demand he also
asked for the Caste census findings conducted under UPA in 2011 be made public.
He correctly states that, “The data will provide evidence if Other Backward Classes (OBC), Dalits,
and Adivasis don't have enough representation in the country's politics
proportionate to their population”
In contrast BJP is
trying to dodge the issue. A party which could undertake the massive and
painful exercise of NRC in Assam; is rejecting caste census! It told the Supreme
Court (2021) that such a census would be "administratively difficult and
cumbersome" and that it was a "conscious policy decision" to
exclude such information from the census purview.”
The real intent of BJP regarding social justice becomes clear at
the times of crucial decisions. Its decision to oppose caste census is one
such. During last nine years the, introduction of reservations for
‘Economically Weaker Sections’ of society has already diluted the prevailing
provisions and upper caste with income of 8 lakhs will also be eligible for
reservations. Economic backwardness has never been in consideration for
reservation, as the very concept of reservation was related to caste
backwardness, caste as a handicap for one’s place in the society.
Coming back to celebrating Ambedkar Anniversary, it is clear
that for parties like BJP Ambedkar’s principles don’t matter. As a matter of
fact Hindu nationalist politics came up precisely to oppose the rising
assertion of SC/SC/OBC. The foundational ideological pronouncements of this
politics glorified the holy tomes and traditions boosting the caste and gender
hierarchy. Today what we need is a genuine assessment of the population of
different marginalized sections and to modify our policies so that the uneven
growth of the society is brought on path of equality. Also the deaths of likes
of Rohith Vemula and Darshan Solanki should awaken us to the need to combat the
biases constructed against the SC/ST/OBC and strive for a future where
‘annihilation of caste’ is the central credo of our society.
No comments:
Post a Comment