As an outside observer who has been watching events in Bangladesh from the USA for the past three decades, I was in a precarious position to find myself in Bangladesh when the Peel Khana massacre took place. I say precarious because I am afraid if the government had taken the path of military confrontation, something that was suggested by (Retd.) Maj. Gen. Mir Shawkat Ali, I believe the potential for a high death toll was very high. Mind that the military action would have turned into what is commonly called in Marxism, a class struggle -- between the Army (the haves) and the BDR (the have-nots). The fight would not have remained confined within some culprit elements of the BDR (irrespective of whether or not they were truly from inside or outside) but all the BDR jawans - some 50,000 strong -- not just those 7,000 confined inside the HQ at the time but also those stationed outside in all the camps and border postings, who would have taken arms to kill their commanding officers everywhere. Truly, it is never easy to bring down such rebels without risking lives of too many, esp. when the HQ itself is located within the heart of the capital city, and the event being watched by too many bystanders - the so-called hujuge Bangladeshis. Worse still the unfolding scenario could have led to the fall of the civilian government, putting the nation into an uncertain future.
Suffice it to say that it was a shocking experience to me. Too many folks that I had come to know over the last 40 years died in that sad event. Many of them were brilliant and honest officers, a combination that is rare in today's Bangladesh! Just like any accidental death, all of them were at the wrong place at the wrong time! Destiny took some of them there to be slaughtered like lambs. Their murder is sickening and despicable. It once again shows how terrible human beings can be when they go violent and lose their mind.
I am saddened to see the slow progress in investigation to finding the root cause(s) and the culprits. With every passing day, such delays are only allowing our people to lend their ears to gossips and rumors, mostly spread by people that have no love either for Bangladesh or its people. In this age of the Internet, rumors multiply too fast! Charlatans are trying to fill the communication vacuum to sell their 'expertise' with a plethora of possibilities and innuendos. Interestingly, some of these outside 'experts' seem to know more than our internal experts, which makes us all wonder about the veracity of the stories that they feed! People are getting confused. They don't know what to believe and whom to believe. It is thus important that the findings of various intelligence services and CID groups are disclosed to arrest such rumors and let people know the truth, and not convenient lies or misinformation.
Sumon Chakroborty's (CNN) assertion that most senior Army officers were against the transfer of authority to a civilian administration, elected by people, belies the truth - the ground reality. Outside a mere handful, including an ambitious general who has since been made an ambassador, most of the senior ranking army officers had little to do with the affairs of the Caretaker government, nor did they crave for prolonging the regime's life. They surely did not want a repeat of the Ershad era.
As to the investigation on the Peel Khana massacre, my personal observation is that from the very beginning there was an attempt by a certain quarter to remove some highly qualified individuals from the investigation. How much of such replacements owed it to the claim that they had served the interest of previous political or military government, and as such, by default could not be trusted with such a sensitive case, I am not sure; I am, however, inclined to think that the culture of jealousy that is so rampant within various government organizations is partially to be blamed for such replacements of key figures. When all the media play the same tune, in a democratic system it is often too difficult for any elected govt. to ignore their thesis. It seems that the AL govt. fell for such a trap. It is so sickening now to find that the same media that had once made such a hue and cry about appointment of those individuals early on in the aftermath of the massacre and were able to force their replacement by the government are now questioning whether they would get the real truth ever. Whose interest is our print media protecting? I don't know, but their integrity is wanting and much to be desired. Some are even feeding info from known enemies of our people simply because their thesis agrees with their polarized views! That is travesty of journalism!
Friday, April 10, 2009
Monday, April 6, 2009
Smear Campaigns by anti-Muslim Bigots
William Gomes, a Catholic missionary activist, has been trying to make an impression in the Internet lately with whole bunch of silly, and yet explosive, arguments and accusations about Islamic terrorism. In those loaded and half-baked statements, he did not have problem in accusing all Islamic NGOs as being fascist organizations that support terrorism (see News From Bangladesh, March 31, 2009). Lately, he claims that ARNO and RSO - two Rohingya organizations - got trained along side the Taliban in Afghanistan. Such accusations by pro-Myanmar regime supporters and activists are not new. It is interesting to find the Catholic zealot - Gomes - tying his knots with the hated SPDC regime. What next is under the sleeves of this Jesuit preacher, a self-styled human rights activist? His accusations on Rohingyas are totally false and ludicrous.
Unfortunately, in the post-9/11 era that we live in, stupid accusations like his go a long way and create an environment of anger, suspicion and violence. In places where Muslims are minority, such anger can easily turn into violence directed against them by chauvinist Christians, and others. And that is why it is important that Gomes's fabricated accusations be condemned severely by all concerned human beings, irrespective of their faith and creed.
As to the rest of the story in his piece, let me just point out that Bush's invasion of Afghanistan has not been popular around the world, not just inside Bangladesh but even in India, Europe and the Americas. Just read the statements by celebrities like Arundhati Roy to see how they felt. Even after all these years, America is unpopular in many places around the world. Just look at the protests against Obama's recent trip to Europe, in spite of his personal charm and popularity. The chants heard inside Bangladesh truly are not too far from those chanted outside Bangladesh - which may not sound that kosher today - but were reflective of the anti-USA anger and sentiment prevalent then throughout the world. Now to connect those slogans with a sweeping remark that Bangladesh has become a terrorist den is not analysis but lack of common sense, resembling crass stupidity.
As to the matter of HuJi or JMB, suffice it to say that these are marginal groups that have already been dealt a fatal blow by the government of Bangladesh. These extremes never had any grass root support inside the country, and as such, Bangladesh's polity has all along rejected those messengers of violence - as is quite clear from the latest national election. In that election, even an otherwise important party (JI) that one time had been a partner in a coalition government was solidly rejected by the electorates. While to a biased chauvinist who is willing to blame Bangladesh and her people, no matter what, such voting records still may not be too convincing, but to an unbiased observer, including the USA Ambassador to Bangladesh - Mr. Moriarty - those results spoke louder than empty words or silly accusations made by pen-pushing pundits and hate-mongering parrots like Gomes. I wish I could say the same thing about India. Alas, there hate mongering groups (responsible for pogroms against Muslims and Christians) like the BJP not only ran the country before, they may still capture the seat of government in the future. Just also look at Israel where a racist, fascist party - Likud - has come to power again. So much so for our democracy! But who is taking notice of such developments, when the messengers of hatred are working towards bringing about the Armageddon in our lifetime by dividing our world into hateful camps, in which, obviously, Islam and Muslims are all dumped together in one corner? With the defeat of Bush and his protégé Sarah-McCain in the USA election, we have been spared of that madness. But that does not deter Bible-thumping pedophile Catholics to either blow the whistle of Armageddon or work as Devil's advocate. They know that intelligent people can read through their lines and know their true agenda too well. Thus, they try to hide their evil self behind epithets like human rights activist and so on and so forth, while they are not. Truly, they fool no one but themselves. The plan of the devil is ever weak. They are right-wing Christian fanatics, the robots of Huntington's “clash of civilizations”, that would lie and distort so that the second coming of their lord can be accelerated on this earth.
Shame on them and shame on their politics!
Unfortunately, in the post-9/11 era that we live in, stupid accusations like his go a long way and create an environment of anger, suspicion and violence. In places where Muslims are minority, such anger can easily turn into violence directed against them by chauvinist Christians, and others. And that is why it is important that Gomes's fabricated accusations be condemned severely by all concerned human beings, irrespective of their faith and creed.
As to the rest of the story in his piece, let me just point out that Bush's invasion of Afghanistan has not been popular around the world, not just inside Bangladesh but even in India, Europe and the Americas. Just read the statements by celebrities like Arundhati Roy to see how they felt. Even after all these years, America is unpopular in many places around the world. Just look at the protests against Obama's recent trip to Europe, in spite of his personal charm and popularity. The chants heard inside Bangladesh truly are not too far from those chanted outside Bangladesh - which may not sound that kosher today - but were reflective of the anti-USA anger and sentiment prevalent then throughout the world. Now to connect those slogans with a sweeping remark that Bangladesh has become a terrorist den is not analysis but lack of common sense, resembling crass stupidity.
As to the matter of HuJi or JMB, suffice it to say that these are marginal groups that have already been dealt a fatal blow by the government of Bangladesh. These extremes never had any grass root support inside the country, and as such, Bangladesh's polity has all along rejected those messengers of violence - as is quite clear from the latest national election. In that election, even an otherwise important party (JI) that one time had been a partner in a coalition government was solidly rejected by the electorates. While to a biased chauvinist who is willing to blame Bangladesh and her people, no matter what, such voting records still may not be too convincing, but to an unbiased observer, including the USA Ambassador to Bangladesh - Mr. Moriarty - those results spoke louder than empty words or silly accusations made by pen-pushing pundits and hate-mongering parrots like Gomes. I wish I could say the same thing about India. Alas, there hate mongering groups (responsible for pogroms against Muslims and Christians) like the BJP not only ran the country before, they may still capture the seat of government in the future. Just also look at Israel where a racist, fascist party - Likud - has come to power again. So much so for our democracy! But who is taking notice of such developments, when the messengers of hatred are working towards bringing about the Armageddon in our lifetime by dividing our world into hateful camps, in which, obviously, Islam and Muslims are all dumped together in one corner? With the defeat of Bush and his protégé Sarah-McCain in the USA election, we have been spared of that madness. But that does not deter Bible-thumping pedophile Catholics to either blow the whistle of Armageddon or work as Devil's advocate. They know that intelligent people can read through their lines and know their true agenda too well. Thus, they try to hide their evil self behind epithets like human rights activist and so on and so forth, while they are not. Truly, they fool no one but themselves. The plan of the devil is ever weak. They are right-wing Christian fanatics, the robots of Huntington's “clash of civilizations”, that would lie and distort so that the second coming of their lord can be accelerated on this earth.
Shame on them and shame on their politics!
Separation of the Judiciary from Administrative branch of the Government - Should we be concerned?
In a recent write-up in the News From Bangladesh, Advocate K.M. Mukta strongly argues in favor of separation of Judiciary and Administrative branches of the government. The matter of separation between these two branches has long been debated since the birth of Pakistan. Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib was a great proponent himself. In general, most opposition politicians have favored the separation one time or another. However, when those same politicians went to power they seemed to dodge the matter for one reason or another.
The decision by the former Care Taker Government to eventually separate the two branches of the government was the fulfillment of that long awaited wish. It is expected that the current Jatiya Sangshad will ratify the Act. People's expectation is that it should work for their benefit and not make things any worse.
There is now doubt that the separation of judiciary from administration has really worked great for most western governments, which have a long history of democracy and respect for law and order. The question in the mind of many concerned Bangladeshis is: will this separation do the same good for a corruption infested society like Bangladesh where rumors are that judges and magistrates today are not above corruption and can be bought for the right price? I pray and hope that such concerns are not true. But if this view is true, then what sort of remedy can we expect for a victim whose rights have been violated and trust in the system misused?
A corrupt magistrate, e.g., can issue an arrest warrant against an innocent person and there is nothing that the latter could do but appeal to the same magistrate or try his luck in a higher court. Mind that appealing for bail petition in the High Court is neither free nor cheap, and may actually cost hundreds of lakh taka -- a sum of money, which is not so easily affordable to most Bangladeshis that don't have access to black (or ill-gotten) money.
Do my concerns here sound outlandish, improbable? But facts are sometimes stranger than fiction. For our purpose here, I shall cite two real examples, both from Chittagong. I am told by a court insider in the Judge's Court in Chittagong, who wanted to remain anonymous, that he knew about the payment of a lakh taka that was made last year by the (dishonest) pleader of a powerful land-grabbing syndicate to a corrupt judge so that the crime syndicate would not be found guilty for its horrendous crimes against some genuine land-owners. The crime, aided at the time by a powerful BNP-MP, included, among others -- destruction of some nine homes, eviction of 16 tenant families, and cutting down of hundreds of teak, mahogany, and other expensive trees from the land-owner's premises. For the sheer luck of it, fortunately for the victims who had filed the criminal case against the crime syndicate, the judge Nitai Chandra Saha was soon transferred to another court. A new judge, Ekramul Hoque Chowdhury - who was honest, found the crime syndicate guilty and sentenced nine members, each to a total of 6.5 year prison term. However, after serving only a month in the prison, all the members were able to get bail from the High Court. Free on bail, the syndicate has gone back to its old evil ways, and has been harassing genuine owners of the land with a plethora of false cases, let alone physical threats.
So ridiculous and untrue were all those charges against the genuine land owners that the Police Investigating Officer recommended charging the accusing syndicate members with Article 211 for harassment of the innocent. All such charges were eventually rejected by the court.
Seeing that their ploys to grabbing land would be futile, thanks to some honest, God-fearing officers of the Chittagong Metropolitan Police department, the syndicate members recently came up with an even more sinister scheme that included falsely accusing the genuine land owners of intention to kill the syndicate chief - Jaker Hosain Chowdhury – an ex-Madrasa daptari, who likes to introduce himself as Jaker master. He charged that on February 16, 2009, at the indication of a daughter of the land-owner, her husband had attacked him with an ax on his head. When he had fallen on the ground, her 82-year old father grabbed and squeezed his testicles (what else ?), while her sister's husband kicked him mercilessly. The alleged crime scene was the owner's premises situated on a very busy road (of course, Jaker claims it to be his!!), and the time of the crime - the broad day light of 1400 hours.
Interestingly, the land-owner's property, fearing any intrusion from the criminal syndicate, has been under Ansar guard for quite some time. A curious visit by any inquiring officer would have been sufficient to see the absolute absurdity of the charges. There was not an iota of truth in this false charge.
But this time, instead of going through the usual channel, which required police inquiry, the syndicate's pleader (an utterly dishonest and immoral scoundrel) went directly to a magistrate the next day and was able to get an arrest warrant issued that very day against the innocent landowners. No police inquiries were required and nothing was verified. No supporting medical reports were also attached with the charges. And yet, it was that easy to dupe or influence the additional CMM in issuing that arrest warrant against four absolutely innocent human beings. The two male accused were not even in the town on that day. The 82-year old land-owner takes a nap at the time, mentioned in the false charges. Interestingly, to misdirect the magistrate, he was shown as a 52-year old man, and his daughter who herself is 53 was shown as a 38-year old lady. The age of the two others accused were also lowered significantly. How could the magistrate overlook the improbable age difference between the daughter and the father, who are accused of committing the crime? Was it an honest mistake, an oversight, on the part of the magistrate?
You wonder - how could this happen in Bangladesh? Imagine the traumatic experience of the old man who could barely bend to find himself accused of squeezing someone else's balls, and then been issued an arrest warrant against him!
The charges were so ludicrous that when these were brought to the attention of the country's two top law men, they had a good laugh, but were genuinely perturbed as to what was happening in the country.
The law minister deplored the fact that corruption had become so rampant, there was very little that his office could stop such victimization of the innocent. He said that there were already too many good laws, but if judges and magistrates took bribe, duped by immoral pleaders and criminals, and did pass unjust and immoral verdicts that victimized the innocent, nothing much could be done to redress the problem. His office had no control over the affairs of the magistrate and that only the chief justice of the Supreme Court could do something to correct the wrong.
These are surely shocking facts of our judiciary system that we may not like to hear. Does the separation of this branch empower our citizens or transform them to lame ducks? Should we or should not we be concerned?
The decision by the former Care Taker Government to eventually separate the two branches of the government was the fulfillment of that long awaited wish. It is expected that the current Jatiya Sangshad will ratify the Act. People's expectation is that it should work for their benefit and not make things any worse.
There is now doubt that the separation of judiciary from administration has really worked great for most western governments, which have a long history of democracy and respect for law and order. The question in the mind of many concerned Bangladeshis is: will this separation do the same good for a corruption infested society like Bangladesh where rumors are that judges and magistrates today are not above corruption and can be bought for the right price? I pray and hope that such concerns are not true. But if this view is true, then what sort of remedy can we expect for a victim whose rights have been violated and trust in the system misused?
A corrupt magistrate, e.g., can issue an arrest warrant against an innocent person and there is nothing that the latter could do but appeal to the same magistrate or try his luck in a higher court. Mind that appealing for bail petition in the High Court is neither free nor cheap, and may actually cost hundreds of lakh taka -- a sum of money, which is not so easily affordable to most Bangladeshis that don't have access to black (or ill-gotten) money.
Do my concerns here sound outlandish, improbable? But facts are sometimes stranger than fiction. For our purpose here, I shall cite two real examples, both from Chittagong. I am told by a court insider in the Judge's Court in Chittagong, who wanted to remain anonymous, that he knew about the payment of a lakh taka that was made last year by the (dishonest) pleader of a powerful land-grabbing syndicate to a corrupt judge so that the crime syndicate would not be found guilty for its horrendous crimes against some genuine land-owners. The crime, aided at the time by a powerful BNP-MP, included, among others -- destruction of some nine homes, eviction of 16 tenant families, and cutting down of hundreds of teak, mahogany, and other expensive trees from the land-owner's premises. For the sheer luck of it, fortunately for the victims who had filed the criminal case against the crime syndicate, the judge Nitai Chandra Saha was soon transferred to another court. A new judge, Ekramul Hoque Chowdhury - who was honest, found the crime syndicate guilty and sentenced nine members, each to a total of 6.5 year prison term. However, after serving only a month in the prison, all the members were able to get bail from the High Court. Free on bail, the syndicate has gone back to its old evil ways, and has been harassing genuine owners of the land with a plethora of false cases, let alone physical threats.
So ridiculous and untrue were all those charges against the genuine land owners that the Police Investigating Officer recommended charging the accusing syndicate members with Article 211 for harassment of the innocent. All such charges were eventually rejected by the court.
Seeing that their ploys to grabbing land would be futile, thanks to some honest, God-fearing officers of the Chittagong Metropolitan Police department, the syndicate members recently came up with an even more sinister scheme that included falsely accusing the genuine land owners of intention to kill the syndicate chief - Jaker Hosain Chowdhury – an ex-Madrasa daptari, who likes to introduce himself as Jaker master. He charged that on February 16, 2009, at the indication of a daughter of the land-owner, her husband had attacked him with an ax on his head. When he had fallen on the ground, her 82-year old father grabbed and squeezed his testicles (what else ?), while her sister's husband kicked him mercilessly. The alleged crime scene was the owner's premises situated on a very busy road (of course, Jaker claims it to be his!!), and the time of the crime - the broad day light of 1400 hours.
Interestingly, the land-owner's property, fearing any intrusion from the criminal syndicate, has been under Ansar guard for quite some time. A curious visit by any inquiring officer would have been sufficient to see the absolute absurdity of the charges. There was not an iota of truth in this false charge.
But this time, instead of going through the usual channel, which required police inquiry, the syndicate's pleader (an utterly dishonest and immoral scoundrel) went directly to a magistrate the next day and was able to get an arrest warrant issued that very day against the innocent landowners. No police inquiries were required and nothing was verified. No supporting medical reports were also attached with the charges. And yet, it was that easy to dupe or influence the additional CMM in issuing that arrest warrant against four absolutely innocent human beings. The two male accused were not even in the town on that day. The 82-year old land-owner takes a nap at the time, mentioned in the false charges. Interestingly, to misdirect the magistrate, he was shown as a 52-year old man, and his daughter who herself is 53 was shown as a 38-year old lady. The age of the two others accused were also lowered significantly. How could the magistrate overlook the improbable age difference between the daughter and the father, who are accused of committing the crime? Was it an honest mistake, an oversight, on the part of the magistrate?
You wonder - how could this happen in Bangladesh? Imagine the traumatic experience of the old man who could barely bend to find himself accused of squeezing someone else's balls, and then been issued an arrest warrant against him!
The charges were so ludicrous that when these were brought to the attention of the country's two top law men, they had a good laugh, but were genuinely perturbed as to what was happening in the country.
The law minister deplored the fact that corruption had become so rampant, there was very little that his office could stop such victimization of the innocent. He said that there were already too many good laws, but if judges and magistrates took bribe, duped by immoral pleaders and criminals, and did pass unjust and immoral verdicts that victimized the innocent, nothing much could be done to redress the problem. His office had no control over the affairs of the magistrate and that only the chief justice of the Supreme Court could do something to correct the wrong.
These are surely shocking facts of our judiciary system that we may not like to hear. Does the separation of this branch empower our citizens or transform them to lame ducks? Should we or should not we be concerned?
Sunita Paul’s Allegations – are these part of a concerted agenda to destabilize the current Bangladesh Government?
In recent months, Sunita Paul has drawn much curiosity from many Bangladeshis. She has been introduced to us as a 57-year old Indian journalist who is an expert on South Asia. However, a thorough scrutiny only reveals that she is no expert on anything; she was virtually unknown in the print media before 2008. Worse still, she has ties with the anti-Muslim bigots and activists in the Zionist, Christian-right and Indian triangle of evil that has agenda which are not good for Bangladesh and her people. For the last few years American Chronicle and Global Politician where she writes are at the fore front of that assault. Interestingly, the American Chronicle has also been posting articles from Salah Uddin Shoaib Choudhury of the Blitz, a very controversial journalist with dubious background. His connection with Richard Benkin, a pro-Israel lobbyist, is well-known to many of us. Lest we forget, the same Mr. Benkin was hired by the BNP Government as a PR campaigner, at the behest of Mr. Lutfozzaman Babar (then the Home Minister) at a monthly retainer fee of $5000 in 2005.
Who is Sunita Paul really? We may never know, since her true identity is shrouded in charade and misinformation. The American Chronicle where she writes tells us that “Born as a deaf and dumb, Sunita Paul decided to use pen in expressing herself.” [http://www.americanchronicle.com/authors/view/2950] Then we read her interview with Kazi Azizul Huq, International Affairs Secretary of the Bangladesh Khilafat Andolon. It is not difficult to understand the reason behind the interview: Bangladesh Khelafat Andolan supports withdrawal of travel ban on Israel. So one wonders how a born deaf and dumb conducted her interview of Mr. Huq, unless this was done via email exchanges!
Sunita has campaigned for Salah Uddin Shoaib Chowdhury, a person whom she admired much. In her own blogspot sunitapaul.blogspot.com though, she claimed that Shoaib tried to molest her on September 2, 2008. In her own words, “I went to Shoaib's residence today to take my update about his case. I was sitting in his murky drawing room when he entered there drunk. Upon some gibberish words, he suddenly grabbed me hard and tried to molest me. I tried to push him off and when I failed, I screamed. Some domestic help came to the spot and rescued me. I left his house immediately. I now know that behind the veil of his international fake image of peace lover, Shoaib is a true criminal. Hence I am withdrawing all the good things that I wrote about him. Death to that bastard!” And yet, in a March 6, 2009 article she writes, “If the judges of Nobel Peace Prize Committee are looking for a real Hero of today’s world to decorate with the most prestigious prize, they surely will not find anyone else except Choudhury, who certainly fits the criteria very precisely.” [“Bangladesh’s Real Hero and the Nobel Peace Prize,” American Chronicle] Probably, the two have been able to patch things up. Can Bangladesh Embassy in India confirm issuing her visa so as to validate her claim that she was in Bangladesh on and around September 2, 2008?
In a March 30, 2008 post in the Asian Tribune.com, Sunita called Bangladesh “a notorious Jew hater and anti West and anti American nation.” [They Hate US-West too by Sunita Paul] It is sad to see that in recent months, many media barons in Bangladesh that are upset with Awami League's victory in the last election are giving her all the access she has been craving for. Little do these people realize that tying knots with a devil is a no win situation. Devil's intention is ever bad! Truly, we don't need an outsider with no love for Bangladesh and her people to tell us what is wrong with us and how to fix it. Even if such people were to diagnose a problem right, they would offer solutions that are deadly. Let's not forget what their ultimate intentions are before we get too excited with their thesis.
Again, Sunita is part of a nexus that would do everything that is possible to divide our people and strengthen the hands of groups that would undermine our sovereignty and freedom. This does not, however, mean that our government in Bangladesh should evade answering many such questions posed by her, because silence in the time of panic or confusion is a foolish strategy; it can threaten the very stability of the government. As we can all testify the delay in the government disclosure of the inquiry report on Peel Khana massacre is already having a devastating ripple effect on our people that are now paying more attention to rumors and believing in stories that may have little to do with the facts behind the massacre. The government is doing a blunder here by not putting a lid on such rumors! It must disclose the truth and nothing but the truth fast.
Sunita claims that the Hasina government is pushing the country to a one-party rule. I personally would like to believe that the current government is serious about multi-party democracy and won’t do anything utterly stupid. Sunita's attempt suggesting otherwise is ignoble and nothing short of fear-mongering and creating an environment of confusion, mistrust and panic that would only weaken our national fabric. We can’t afford it. Not now anyway.
End Notes:
Interested readers may also like to read the blogs below to draw their own conclusions:
http://www.globalpolitician.com/23012-bangladesh
http://www.freechoudhury.com/RichardBio.htm
http://bdosintmonitors.blogspot.com/
http://www.freechoudhury.com/Arvind%20Ghosh%20Memorial%20Lecture.pdf
http://www.docstrangelove.com/2009/04/03/sunita-paul-plagiarist/comment-page-1/;
http://www.freechoudhury.com/ShoaibBio.htm; http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=8648
http://unitedblackuntouchablesworldwide.blogspot.com/2008/08/sunita-pauls-attack-on-barrister-tania.html
http://chottala.blogspot.com/2009/04/chottalacom-mystry-of-ficticious-ms.html
http://www.boycottbangladesh.org/
http://www.globalpolitician.com/24891-wto-bangladesh
http://bangladeshkhelafatandolan.blogspot.com/2008/06/interview-with-sunita-paul.html
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/93529
http://sunitapaul.blogspot.com/
http://www.asiantribune.com/?q=node/1025
Who is Sunita Paul really? We may never know, since her true identity is shrouded in charade and misinformation. The American Chronicle where she writes tells us that “Born as a deaf and dumb, Sunita Paul decided to use pen in expressing herself.” [http://www.americanchronicle.com/authors/view/2950] Then we read her interview with Kazi Azizul Huq, International Affairs Secretary of the Bangladesh Khilafat Andolon. It is not difficult to understand the reason behind the interview: Bangladesh Khelafat Andolan supports withdrawal of travel ban on Israel. So one wonders how a born deaf and dumb conducted her interview of Mr. Huq, unless this was done via email exchanges!
Sunita has campaigned for Salah Uddin Shoaib Chowdhury, a person whom she admired much. In her own blogspot sunitapaul.blogspot.com though, she claimed that Shoaib tried to molest her on September 2, 2008. In her own words, “I went to Shoaib's residence today to take my update about his case. I was sitting in his murky drawing room when he entered there drunk. Upon some gibberish words, he suddenly grabbed me hard and tried to molest me. I tried to push him off and when I failed, I screamed. Some domestic help came to the spot and rescued me. I left his house immediately. I now know that behind the veil of his international fake image of peace lover, Shoaib is a true criminal. Hence I am withdrawing all the good things that I wrote about him. Death to that bastard!” And yet, in a March 6, 2009 article she writes, “If the judges of Nobel Peace Prize Committee are looking for a real Hero of today’s world to decorate with the most prestigious prize, they surely will not find anyone else except Choudhury, who certainly fits the criteria very precisely.” [“Bangladesh’s Real Hero and the Nobel Peace Prize,” American Chronicle] Probably, the two have been able to patch things up. Can Bangladesh Embassy in India confirm issuing her visa so as to validate her claim that she was in Bangladesh on and around September 2, 2008?
In a March 30, 2008 post in the Asian Tribune.com, Sunita called Bangladesh “a notorious Jew hater and anti West and anti American nation.” [They Hate US-West too by Sunita Paul] It is sad to see that in recent months, many media barons in Bangladesh that are upset with Awami League's victory in the last election are giving her all the access she has been craving for. Little do these people realize that tying knots with a devil is a no win situation. Devil's intention is ever bad! Truly, we don't need an outsider with no love for Bangladesh and her people to tell us what is wrong with us and how to fix it. Even if such people were to diagnose a problem right, they would offer solutions that are deadly. Let's not forget what their ultimate intentions are before we get too excited with their thesis.
Again, Sunita is part of a nexus that would do everything that is possible to divide our people and strengthen the hands of groups that would undermine our sovereignty and freedom. This does not, however, mean that our government in Bangladesh should evade answering many such questions posed by her, because silence in the time of panic or confusion is a foolish strategy; it can threaten the very stability of the government. As we can all testify the delay in the government disclosure of the inquiry report on Peel Khana massacre is already having a devastating ripple effect on our people that are now paying more attention to rumors and believing in stories that may have little to do with the facts behind the massacre. The government is doing a blunder here by not putting a lid on such rumors! It must disclose the truth and nothing but the truth fast.
Sunita claims that the Hasina government is pushing the country to a one-party rule. I personally would like to believe that the current government is serious about multi-party democracy and won’t do anything utterly stupid. Sunita's attempt suggesting otherwise is ignoble and nothing short of fear-mongering and creating an environment of confusion, mistrust and panic that would only weaken our national fabric. We can’t afford it. Not now anyway.
End Notes:
Interested readers may also like to read the blogs below to draw their own conclusions:
http://www.globalpolitician.com/23012-bangladesh
http://www.freechoudhury.com/RichardBio.htm
http://bdosintmonitors.blogspot.com/
http://www.freechoudhury.com/Arvind%20Ghosh%20Memorial%20Lecture.pdf
http://www.docstrangelove.com/2009/04/03/sunita-paul-plagiarist/comment-page-1/;
http://www.freechoudhury.com/ShoaibBio.htm; http://www.rsf.org/article.php3?id_article=8648
http://unitedblackuntouchablesworldwide.blogspot.com/2008/08/sunita-pauls-attack-on-barrister-tania.html
http://chottala.blogspot.com/2009/04/chottalacom-mystry-of-ficticious-ms.html
http://www.boycottbangladesh.org/
http://www.globalpolitician.com/24891-wto-bangladesh
http://bangladeshkhelafatandolan.blogspot.com/2008/06/interview-with-sunita-paul.html
http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/93529
http://sunitapaul.blogspot.com/
http://www.asiantribune.com/?q=node/1025
Israeli criminals must be prosecuted for their war crimes in Gaza
Ref: .nytimes.com/2009/04/04/opinion/04bisharat.html?ref=global&pagewanted=print
As rightly pointed out by Professor George Bisharat (Israel on Trial, the N.Y. Times, op/ed, April 4, 2009) the stature of international law is diminished when a nation violates it with impunity. For years, Israel has been guilty of violating international laws, and yet, our own U.S. government either condoned such crimes or chose to close its eyes. Unfortunately, such an attitude has only emboldened the Israeli hardliners into tightening ever harder the screws for inhuman suffocation of the Palestinian people that live under occupation. Truly, in recent months what the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) did in the Gaza (often termed the “most despicable place on earth”) from willful murder of unarmed civilians to destruction of the entire infrastructure is nothing short of war crimes.
It is high time that the Obama Administration tries to reclaim the moral higher ground through its actions that speak loud and clear that America condemns all such atrocities and won’t tolerate any repeat of such crimes in the future. Israeli political and military personnel who planned, ordered or executed those offenses should face criminal prosecution.
As rightly pointed out by Professor George Bisharat (Israel on Trial, the N.Y. Times, op/ed, April 4, 2009) the stature of international law is diminished when a nation violates it with impunity. For years, Israel has been guilty of violating international laws, and yet, our own U.S. government either condoned such crimes or chose to close its eyes. Unfortunately, such an attitude has only emboldened the Israeli hardliners into tightening ever harder the screws for inhuman suffocation of the Palestinian people that live under occupation. Truly, in recent months what the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) did in the Gaza (often termed the “most despicable place on earth”) from willful murder of unarmed civilians to destruction of the entire infrastructure is nothing short of war crimes.
It is high time that the Obama Administration tries to reclaim the moral higher ground through its actions that speak loud and clear that America condemns all such atrocities and won’t tolerate any repeat of such crimes in the future. Israeli political and military personnel who planned, ordered or executed those offenses should face criminal prosecution.
Sunday, March 29, 2009
Comments on a ultra-nationalist, racist Rakhine's interpretation of Rohingya history
Khin Maung Saw's thesis on trying to de-legitimatize the Rohingya history in Arakan is not new. For the last three years, as an obsessed, xenophobic Rakhine, much given to pen-pushing, and spread of hateful messages, he is known for trying his best to re-write history that would obliterate Rohingya's historicity in today's Arakan. His pseudo-history has been already refuted by others.
In this short rebuttal, let me point out something that I have maintained in last three decades, is that the history of the geographical region we commonly came to know as the South Asia including what is today called Myanmar, which is sandwiched between South Asia and South-east Asia, has no one beginning, no one chronology, no single plot or narrative. This gargantuan fact is recognized by all great historians -- Professor David Ludden (who recently retired from the U Penn), Romila Thapar, R.S. Sharma and many others -- who spent their lifetimes to study the region. To these unbiased and genuine historians of the ancient India and Burma, the region did not have a singular history, but many histories, with indefinite, contested origins and with countless separate trajectories that multiply the more we learn about the region. Obviously, such an understanding and analysis of history is unpopular and loathsome with communal, racist, xenophobic regimes and their propagandists and vanguards. The latter bigots would rather have it their way in which the minorities or the have-nots in power simply did neither exist nor mattered. To them, the affected persecuted people just appeared in the recent scene through mere accident of history like those possible through a magic lantern! That is the level of their disgusting chauvinism, which is often reflected through the claims and counter-claims of pen-pushing polemicists like Khin Maung Saw.
I am sure if half-educated charlatans like Khin Maung Saw had genuinely tried to study history from a neutral mindset, away from malice and hatred, our world, especially that of the South-Asia and South-east Asia would have been quite different. We would not have hateful criminals like the SPDC and BJP ruling either Burma or India. Through their communal interpretation of history, these two-legged animals have given credence to the Darwinist interpretation of the origin of species that in places like Buddhist Burma there are still entities that have not fully evolved into human beings. With all the signs we see around us from these half-beasts, half-men, I am afraid we may not see their full evolution in our lifetime!
In this short rebuttal, let me point out something that I have maintained in last three decades, is that the history of the geographical region we commonly came to know as the South Asia including what is today called Myanmar, which is sandwiched between South Asia and South-east Asia, has no one beginning, no one chronology, no single plot or narrative. This gargantuan fact is recognized by all great historians -- Professor David Ludden (who recently retired from the U Penn), Romila Thapar, R.S. Sharma and many others -- who spent their lifetimes to study the region. To these unbiased and genuine historians of the ancient India and Burma, the region did not have a singular history, but many histories, with indefinite, contested origins and with countless separate trajectories that multiply the more we learn about the region. Obviously, such an understanding and analysis of history is unpopular and loathsome with communal, racist, xenophobic regimes and their propagandists and vanguards. The latter bigots would rather have it their way in which the minorities or the have-nots in power simply did neither exist nor mattered. To them, the affected persecuted people just appeared in the recent scene through mere accident of history like those possible through a magic lantern! That is the level of their disgusting chauvinism, which is often reflected through the claims and counter-claims of pen-pushing polemicists like Khin Maung Saw.
I am sure if half-educated charlatans like Khin Maung Saw had genuinely tried to study history from a neutral mindset, away from malice and hatred, our world, especially that of the South-Asia and South-east Asia would have been quite different. We would not have hateful criminals like the SPDC and BJP ruling either Burma or India. Through their communal interpretation of history, these two-legged animals have given credence to the Darwinist interpretation of the origin of species that in places like Buddhist Burma there are still entities that have not fully evolved into human beings. With all the signs we see around us from these half-beasts, half-men, I am afraid we may not see their full evolution in our lifetime!
The Pursuit of Nuclear Energy in Bangladesh - Facts and Figures to Consider
According to a published news report, the Government of Bangladesh is aggressively targeting to set up at least a 1000 MW nuclear power plant in the country within a decade. The official sources say that currently the Bangladesh government has received three preliminary proposals from Russia, China and South Korea.
The news should come as no surprise given the current government’s promise and commitment to mitigate the appalling energy shortage inside the country. With all the added emphasis on limiting harmful greenhouse effects, it is safe to assume that nuclear energy remains a viable option to meeting Bangladesh’s growing energy needs. It has no “carbon footing” and does not cause climate change. On the other hand, its disadvantages involve the unsafe nature of the process and the exhaustibility of its fuel, e.g., uranium for thermal fission reactors and plutonium for breeder reactors (note: the latter material can be used directly to making “dirty” bombs, while the former requires sophisticated concentration before it can be used in a weapon).
As Bangladesh explores her nuclear option, it is important that we have a good understanding of this technology. The processes used in nuclear power industry start with mining. The basic ingredient is uranium which has the advantage of being an enormous source of energy, and it is easily and cheaply transportable. It exists in nature in three isotopes: U-238 (99.284%), U-235 (0.711%) and U-234 (0.005%). The uranium content is referred to as triuranium octaoxide, U3O8., which is the most common (and stable) form found in nature. Uranium dioxide, UO2, is the form in which uranium is most commonly used as a nuclear reactor fuel. At ambient temperatures, UO2 will gradually convert to U3O8.
Currently, the fuel price of U3O8 is around $50/lb. It is highly likely that the price would reach $100/lb with growing demands, which would inevitably trigger more exploration of mines and their profitable recovery. Experts estimate that the global reserve is around 4-5 million tons. At current global consumption of approximately 77,000 tons/year, this reserve will last only for 65 years. This reserves-to-production (R/P) ratio of 65 is well below coal and only 50% more than oil or natural gas.
Today, nuclear energy supplies only 7.5% of the total global energy consumption, corresponding to 17% of the global electricity consumption. With growing concerns on carbon emission, it is safe to assume that this percentage will grow in coming decades. Unlike fossil fuel based energy options, the nuclear industry is only 55 years old with the first plant built in 1954 in the USSR. Since then, some 575 nuclear power plants have been built around the globe, including 125 in the USA. As of 2008, the installed capacity of all the running plants in the world is 413 GW of which 119 GW is in the USA. The actual electric production, however, is only about 300 GW (and approx. 100 GW in the USA) giving an asset utilization of 73% globally (and 84% for the USA). Of all those plants built since 1954, 439 are still operating, 119 have been shut down. However, since decommissioning of nuclear plants is a highly complicated and expensive process, only 17 (of those 119) plants have really been decommissioned. According to an industry expert, Bela Liptak, three nuclear plants were started in 2007, and currently another 35 are under construction (The Future of Nuclear Energy, Control Magazine, March 2009).
In the USA, in the post-Three Mile Island (TMI-2) nuclear accident (1979) period, because of mounting concerns on safety of operation, risk to living beings plus hazards related to safe disposal of nuclear waste, all applications to build nuclear plants were turned down. Of the already built plants, 13 have been permanently shut down, and 10 have completed their decommissioning. Even after all these years, most Americans don’t favor having a nuclear plant built in their neighborhoods.
The total investment to build an average power nuclear plant is estimated to be over $4 billion. (The typical life of a nuclear power plant is 30 to 60 years.) In spite of such high capital costs (and the need to internalize all waste disposal and decommissioning costs), nuclear energy is, in many places, competitive with fossil fuel for electricity generation. If the social, health and environmental costs of fossil fuels are also taken into account, nuclear is outstanding. In this regard, the 2001 report of a major European study of the external costs of various fuel cycles, focusing on coal and nuclear, ExternE, is quite revealing. It shows that in clear cash terms nuclear energy incurs about one tenth of the costs of coal. The external costs are defined as those actually incurred in relation to health and the environment and quantifiable but not built into the cost of the electricity. If these costs were in fact included, the EU price of electricity from coal would double and that from gas would increase 30%. These are without attempting to include global warming. Nuclear energy averages 0.4 euro cents/kWh, much the same as hydro, coal is over 4.0 cents (4.1-7.3), gas ranges 1.3-2.3 cents and only wind shows up better than nuclear, at 0.1-0.2 cents/kWh average. (Note: these are the external costs only.)
As to the overall breakdown of fuel cost, it is worth noting that uranium has to be processed, enriched and fabricated into fuel elements, and about half of the cost is due to enrichment and fabrication. A January 2007 analysis shows that to make 1 kg of Uranium as UO2 reactor fuel, the cost of 8.9 kg of U3O8 is (USD) $472 (@ $53/kg), the conversion cost for processing 7.5 kg of U (@ $12/kg) is $90, the enrichment cost is $985 and fabrication cost is $240. That is, the total cost for 1 kg of Uranium as UO2 reactor fuel is $ 1787. At 360,000 kWh of electrical power per kg, this translates into 0.50 cents/kWh. Now if we assume a 100% increase in U3O8 price, while other costs (processing, enrichment, fabrication) remain the same, the total cost will be $2286, i.e., only a 28% increase in overall price to 0.635 cents/kWh. Even when the costs for radioactive spent fuel and the ultimate disposal of this spent fuel or the wastes separated from it are factored in, the total fuel costs of a nuclear power plant in the OECD are typically about a third of those for a coal-fired plant and between a quarter and a fifth of those for a gas combined-cycle plant.
Fuel costs are one area of steadily increasing efficiency and cost reduction programs. For instance, in Spain nuclear electricity cost was reduced by 29% over 1995-2001. This involved boosting enrichment levels and burn-up to achieve 40% fuel cost reduction. Prospectively, a further 8% increase in burn-up will give another 5% reduction in fuel cost.
For nuclear power plants any cost figure normally includes spent fuel management, plant decommissioning and final waste disposal. Decommissioning costs are about 9-15% of the initial capital cost of a nuclear power plant. The back-end of the fuel cycle, including used fuel storage or disposal in a waste repository, contributes up to another 10% to the overall costs per kWh, - less if there is direct disposal of used fuel rather than reprocessing.
The US cost figures for 2007 published by the Energy Utility Cost Group showed nuclear utility generating costs averaging 2.866 c/kWh, comprising 1.832 c/kWh for operation and maintenance, 0.449 c/kWh for fuel and 0.585 c/kWh for capital expenditure. An EU 2007 study, on the other hand, compared electricity cost (US cents/kWh): 5.4-7.4 for nuclear, 4.7-6.1 for coal, 4.6-6.1 for gas, 4.7-14.8 for wind in-shore, and 8.2-20.2 for wind off-shore. In January 2009, CEZ published cost for new nuclear plants at 6 euro cents/kWh (comprising of 3.8 cents for capital, 1.0 for fixed cost and 1.2 for fuel cost). Nuclear power is very capital-intensive, while fuel costs are relatively much more significant for systems based on fossil fuels.
Any capital cost figure from a nuclear reactor vendor, or which is general and not site-specific, will usually just be for EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) costs. This is because owner's costs will vary depending on whether a plant is new or at an established site, perhaps replacing an old plant.
Long construction periods will push up financing costs, and in the past they have done so dramatically. It used to take eight to ten years to set up a 600-1000 MW power plant in most countries, as it required fulfilling many conditions for a safe and regulated nuclear plant. In Asia construction times have tended to be shorter. For instance, the new-generation 1300 MWe Japanese reactors which began operating in 1996 and 1997 were built in a little over four years, and 48 to 54 months is typical projection for plants today.
As hinted earlier, in terms of energy generation, one kg of natural uranium is equivalent to 20,000 kg of coal. The fuel's contribution to the overall cost of the electricity produced is relatively small, so even a large fuel price escalation will have relatively little effect. For instance, typically a doubling of the uranium market price would increase the fuel cost for a light water reactor by 28% and the electricity cost about 7%, whereas doubling the gas price would typically add 70% to the price of electricity from that source. (This fact is especially important for countries like Bangladesh in coming years with ever declining supply of oil and gas.) There are other possible savings from nuclear fuel. For example, if spent fuel is reprocessed and the recovered plutonium and uranium is used in mixed oxide (MOX) fuel, more energy can be extracted. The costs of achieving this are large, but are offset by MOX fuel not needing enrichment and particularly by the smaller amount of high-level wastes produced at the end.
The safety record of mining, enrichment and fuel fabrication is fairly good. While nuclear fuel preparation is relatively safe, it is not accident-free. Most nuclear accidents occur in the nuclear reactors themselves. The majority of these accidents are caused by design or operator errors involving either the coolant controls or the fuel rod. Radiation leaks can also occur because of earthquakes, poor waste storage practices, ageing or terrorist attacks. The most important goal is to maintain standard operation of the reactor cooling system. Run-away reactions can evolve too quickly, while plant shut down is slow and complicated. Thus, having backup controls and equipment is more important than in other industrial operations.
As Bangladesh evaluates vendor information on nuclear power plants, it is important that her decision makers are fully cognizant of this technology so that the best possible deal can be sealed that protects the interest of our people.
The news should come as no surprise given the current government’s promise and commitment to mitigate the appalling energy shortage inside the country. With all the added emphasis on limiting harmful greenhouse effects, it is safe to assume that nuclear energy remains a viable option to meeting Bangladesh’s growing energy needs. It has no “carbon footing” and does not cause climate change. On the other hand, its disadvantages involve the unsafe nature of the process and the exhaustibility of its fuel, e.g., uranium for thermal fission reactors and plutonium for breeder reactors (note: the latter material can be used directly to making “dirty” bombs, while the former requires sophisticated concentration before it can be used in a weapon).
As Bangladesh explores her nuclear option, it is important that we have a good understanding of this technology. The processes used in nuclear power industry start with mining. The basic ingredient is uranium which has the advantage of being an enormous source of energy, and it is easily and cheaply transportable. It exists in nature in three isotopes: U-238 (99.284%), U-235 (0.711%) and U-234 (0.005%). The uranium content is referred to as triuranium octaoxide, U3O8., which is the most common (and stable) form found in nature. Uranium dioxide, UO2, is the form in which uranium is most commonly used as a nuclear reactor fuel. At ambient temperatures, UO2 will gradually convert to U3O8.
Currently, the fuel price of U3O8 is around $50/lb. It is highly likely that the price would reach $100/lb with growing demands, which would inevitably trigger more exploration of mines and their profitable recovery. Experts estimate that the global reserve is around 4-5 million tons. At current global consumption of approximately 77,000 tons/year, this reserve will last only for 65 years. This reserves-to-production (R/P) ratio of 65 is well below coal and only 50% more than oil or natural gas.
Today, nuclear energy supplies only 7.5% of the total global energy consumption, corresponding to 17% of the global electricity consumption. With growing concerns on carbon emission, it is safe to assume that this percentage will grow in coming decades. Unlike fossil fuel based energy options, the nuclear industry is only 55 years old with the first plant built in 1954 in the USSR. Since then, some 575 nuclear power plants have been built around the globe, including 125 in the USA. As of 2008, the installed capacity of all the running plants in the world is 413 GW of which 119 GW is in the USA. The actual electric production, however, is only about 300 GW (and approx. 100 GW in the USA) giving an asset utilization of 73% globally (and 84% for the USA). Of all those plants built since 1954, 439 are still operating, 119 have been shut down. However, since decommissioning of nuclear plants is a highly complicated and expensive process, only 17 (of those 119) plants have really been decommissioned. According to an industry expert, Bela Liptak, three nuclear plants were started in 2007, and currently another 35 are under construction (The Future of Nuclear Energy, Control Magazine, March 2009).
In the USA, in the post-Three Mile Island (TMI-2) nuclear accident (1979) period, because of mounting concerns on safety of operation, risk to living beings plus hazards related to safe disposal of nuclear waste, all applications to build nuclear plants were turned down. Of the already built plants, 13 have been permanently shut down, and 10 have completed their decommissioning. Even after all these years, most Americans don’t favor having a nuclear plant built in their neighborhoods.
The total investment to build an average power nuclear plant is estimated to be over $4 billion. (The typical life of a nuclear power plant is 30 to 60 years.) In spite of such high capital costs (and the need to internalize all waste disposal and decommissioning costs), nuclear energy is, in many places, competitive with fossil fuel for electricity generation. If the social, health and environmental costs of fossil fuels are also taken into account, nuclear is outstanding. In this regard, the 2001 report of a major European study of the external costs of various fuel cycles, focusing on coal and nuclear, ExternE, is quite revealing. It shows that in clear cash terms nuclear energy incurs about one tenth of the costs of coal. The external costs are defined as those actually incurred in relation to health and the environment and quantifiable but not built into the cost of the electricity. If these costs were in fact included, the EU price of electricity from coal would double and that from gas would increase 30%. These are without attempting to include global warming. Nuclear energy averages 0.4 euro cents/kWh, much the same as hydro, coal is over 4.0 cents (4.1-7.3), gas ranges 1.3-2.3 cents and only wind shows up better than nuclear, at 0.1-0.2 cents/kWh average. (Note: these are the external costs only.)
As to the overall breakdown of fuel cost, it is worth noting that uranium has to be processed, enriched and fabricated into fuel elements, and about half of the cost is due to enrichment and fabrication. A January 2007 analysis shows that to make 1 kg of Uranium as UO2 reactor fuel, the cost of 8.9 kg of U3O8 is (USD) $472 (@ $53/kg), the conversion cost for processing 7.5 kg of U (@ $12/kg) is $90, the enrichment cost is $985 and fabrication cost is $240. That is, the total cost for 1 kg of Uranium as UO2 reactor fuel is $ 1787. At 360,000 kWh of electrical power per kg, this translates into 0.50 cents/kWh. Now if we assume a 100% increase in U3O8 price, while other costs (processing, enrichment, fabrication) remain the same, the total cost will be $2286, i.e., only a 28% increase in overall price to 0.635 cents/kWh. Even when the costs for radioactive spent fuel and the ultimate disposal of this spent fuel or the wastes separated from it are factored in, the total fuel costs of a nuclear power plant in the OECD are typically about a third of those for a coal-fired plant and between a quarter and a fifth of those for a gas combined-cycle plant.
Fuel costs are one area of steadily increasing efficiency and cost reduction programs. For instance, in Spain nuclear electricity cost was reduced by 29% over 1995-2001. This involved boosting enrichment levels and burn-up to achieve 40% fuel cost reduction. Prospectively, a further 8% increase in burn-up will give another 5% reduction in fuel cost.
For nuclear power plants any cost figure normally includes spent fuel management, plant decommissioning and final waste disposal. Decommissioning costs are about 9-15% of the initial capital cost of a nuclear power plant. The back-end of the fuel cycle, including used fuel storage or disposal in a waste repository, contributes up to another 10% to the overall costs per kWh, - less if there is direct disposal of used fuel rather than reprocessing.
The US cost figures for 2007 published by the Energy Utility Cost Group showed nuclear utility generating costs averaging 2.866 c/kWh, comprising 1.832 c/kWh for operation and maintenance, 0.449 c/kWh for fuel and 0.585 c/kWh for capital expenditure. An EU 2007 study, on the other hand, compared electricity cost (US cents/kWh): 5.4-7.4 for nuclear, 4.7-6.1 for coal, 4.6-6.1 for gas, 4.7-14.8 for wind in-shore, and 8.2-20.2 for wind off-shore. In January 2009, CEZ published cost for new nuclear plants at 6 euro cents/kWh (comprising of 3.8 cents for capital, 1.0 for fixed cost and 1.2 for fuel cost). Nuclear power is very capital-intensive, while fuel costs are relatively much more significant for systems based on fossil fuels.
Any capital cost figure from a nuclear reactor vendor, or which is general and not site-specific, will usually just be for EPC (engineering, procurement and construction) costs. This is because owner's costs will vary depending on whether a plant is new or at an established site, perhaps replacing an old plant.
Long construction periods will push up financing costs, and in the past they have done so dramatically. It used to take eight to ten years to set up a 600-1000 MW power plant in most countries, as it required fulfilling many conditions for a safe and regulated nuclear plant. In Asia construction times have tended to be shorter. For instance, the new-generation 1300 MWe Japanese reactors which began operating in 1996 and 1997 were built in a little over four years, and 48 to 54 months is typical projection for plants today.
As hinted earlier, in terms of energy generation, one kg of natural uranium is equivalent to 20,000 kg of coal. The fuel's contribution to the overall cost of the electricity produced is relatively small, so even a large fuel price escalation will have relatively little effect. For instance, typically a doubling of the uranium market price would increase the fuel cost for a light water reactor by 28% and the electricity cost about 7%, whereas doubling the gas price would typically add 70% to the price of electricity from that source. (This fact is especially important for countries like Bangladesh in coming years with ever declining supply of oil and gas.) There are other possible savings from nuclear fuel. For example, if spent fuel is reprocessed and the recovered plutonium and uranium is used in mixed oxide (MOX) fuel, more energy can be extracted. The costs of achieving this are large, but are offset by MOX fuel not needing enrichment and particularly by the smaller amount of high-level wastes produced at the end.
The safety record of mining, enrichment and fuel fabrication is fairly good. While nuclear fuel preparation is relatively safe, it is not accident-free. Most nuclear accidents occur in the nuclear reactors themselves. The majority of these accidents are caused by design or operator errors involving either the coolant controls or the fuel rod. Radiation leaks can also occur because of earthquakes, poor waste storage practices, ageing or terrorist attacks. The most important goal is to maintain standard operation of the reactor cooling system. Run-away reactions can evolve too quickly, while plant shut down is slow and complicated. Thus, having backup controls and equipment is more important than in other industrial operations.
As Bangladesh evaluates vendor information on nuclear power plants, it is important that her decision makers are fully cognizant of this technology so that the best possible deal can be sealed that protects the interest of our people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Genocide ruling against Myanmar welcome but it highlights good and bad of international law
Alex Cunningham Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu, Joseph Kony. All three men stand accused of slaughtering innocent civilians, abducting...
-
It has become a wallowing cringe. The extolling of multi-culti values, the incessant self-praise of diversity, variety and cosmopolitanis...
-
Check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IibWmU82VKk
-
Subject: Rebuilding the temple VID-20260405-WA0009 .mp4 14.3 MB