Thursday, May 26, 2022

Places of Worship: Striving for Peace and Reconciliation by Ram Puniyani

The ugly head of religious intolerance against Muslims is rising so badly that secularism in India is threatened at its very shaky foundation. Hindutvadi fascists are demanding the destruction of many historical sites under the pretext that they were originally former Hindu sites. These include the Tajmahal, Kutub Minar, Jama masjid and every conceivable major relic of medieval period built by the Muslim kings. The argument is being proffered that  these places be restored to Hindus, to whom they belong and have been wrongfully appropriated/destroyed/modified by the Muslim Kings.

There is no truth to such claims, but in today's India, no one dares to oppose BJP, RSS, Hindu Mahasabah and their hateful messages that call for intolerance and genocide of Muslims. - HS
=============
 Excerpted from a longer article.
==========

The rule of Muslim kings in no way was driven by the goal of spreading Islam or to establish supremacy of Islam. The kings, Muslims or Hindus were ruling in collaboration with the powerful landlords and kings, irrespective of their religion. Be it Muslim kings, Akbar to Aurangzeb; they were associated with the landlords/kings of other religions. Kingdoms were based on feudal system and not around religion. Akbar had Birbal, Todarmal, Mansing and hoard of others’ doing his bidding and he was also getting advice from them. Aurangzeb had nearly 1/3rd Court officials who were Hindus as per Prof Athat Ali’s book.

The wars were not along religious lines. Shivaji’s initial battles were against Hindu king, Chadra Rao More; Sikh Gurus had serious confrontation with Hindu kings who were ruling in neighboring hills. The places of worship might have been destroyed for myriad of reasons, wealth, political rivalries and the rebels against Kings hiding in those places.

The Indian culture has been a mix of cultures of people of diverse religions, Hindus and Muslims in the main. Even Islam did not spread through kings, though some Muslim kings did put the condition of conversion to Islam to the rival king. The mass conversions have been mainly due to the longing of those oppressed by caste system.

To project Hindus as being oppressed by Muslims is off the mark. The economic oppression of Hindus and Muslim poor was at the hands of the landlords for revenue collection. The other oppression was that of caste system which has been the hallmark of Indian society. That’s how Dr. Ambedkar sees the Indian history. He says coming of Buddhism was a revolution as it challenged the caste system. The following period was the period of counter revolution in which there was a massive attack on Buddhists and places of Buddhist worship.

In a way this is the real binary of Indian society. The hegemonic upper caste ideology pitted against the low caste untouchables (later called dalits). The motives behind killings of Buddhists were ideological. Pushyamitra Shung went to the extent of offering a golden coin to anyone who brings the head of a Buddhist monk. This is what wiped out Buddhism from the land of its birth.

During freedom movement it was correctly perceived by the national movement that the British, the colonizers have oppressed us the Indians. So it directed its energies against the British rule. During this period the upholders of upper caste/elite ideology focused on the ‘foreigner’, Muslims and kept aloof from the movement and struggle to throw out British rule. They went to construct the narrative of tyrannical Muslim rule and need to have the Hindu nation. That’s why the very notion of secularism is alien to them and wants to oppose it as a Western concept. Their rooting is in the social system of Kingdoms, where Kings-Landlords ruled and exploited the poor in the name of religion.

The modern state, modernity, has no place for such this landlord-clergy alliance lording over the people. Secularism is a universal value where state looks at the citizen as equal irrespective of one’s religion. The defenders of demolition project and diggers of the past are not only opposed to pluralism and secular values but also are totally blind to the demolitions of places of worship of Buddhist or Jains for that matter. They selectively pick up some few cases and harp on that. This is made to reflect on today’s Muslims and this divisive ideology lays the foundation of hate, violence and polarization.

The increased clout of this ideology is trying to compare the places of religious worship act with farmer’s laws. The places of religious act 1991 was aimed to focus social energies on building the future while preserving the integrative aspects of Indian syncretism, what Nehru underlined as Ganga Jamuna Tehjeeb. This is well reflected in what Goswami Tulsidas in his Kavitavali says, “Tulsi Sarnaam Gulam hai Ramko, Jako Ruche so kae Vohu, Maang ke Khaiboo, Masit ma soibo, Lebe ko Ek no debe ko Do. (My name is Tulsi, I am a slave of Ram. My give and take with the World is done. I live on alms and sleep in a mosque)   


No comments:

Post a Comment

Genocide ruling against Myanmar welcome but it highlights good and bad of international law

  Alex Cunningham Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu, Joseph Kony. All three men stand accused of slaughtering innocent civilians, abducting...