Thursday, October 1, 2026

Palestinian MKs in Israel have long faced election bans. This time is different

 On September 23, Israel’s Central Elections Committee performed its ritual of banning Palestinian parties and candidates, voting to bar the Joint List, comprising Hadash, Balad, and Ta’al, as well as Mansour Abbas’ United Arab List (Ra’am). The committee also voted to disqualify two individual candidates: Hadash lawmaker Ofer Cassif and Balad leader Sami Abu Shehadeh, whose candidacy it rejected by a crushing margin of 31 to 4. 

Since 2003, disqualification proceedings have become a fixture of nearly every election cycle. The committee is indeed an explicitly political body whose composition mirrors the balance of power in the Knesset, and after it votes to exclude Arab parties or candidates, the Supreme Court is then called upon to approve or overturn the decision. 

But the campaign against Abu Shehadeh in particular has broken with the familiar script, in ways that have raised fears that the Supreme Court — which is set to hear his disqualification petition on Thursday — might no longer serve as the backstop it once did. 

The first indication came from Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara. The Elections Committee had barred Abu Shehadeh on two of the three grounds set out in Israel’s Basic Law on the Knesset: negating Israel’s existence as a Jewish and democratic state, and supporting armed struggle by an enemy state or terrorist organization against Israel. (The third is incitement to racism).

Baharav-Miara’s position hardened over the course of the proceedings. Ahead of the Elections Committee hearing, she said there was a basis for the armed struggle allegation and urged the committee to “seriously consider” disqualifying Abu Shehadeh after hearing his response, but stopped short of explicitly endorsing a ban. Two days before the Supreme Court hearing, she went further: In a legal opinion submitted on Tuesday, she explicitly asked the court to uphold his ban on grounds of supporting armed struggle. 

But both she and the committee provided no evidence for this charge other than what was cited in the disqualification bid, filed by Itamar Ben Gvir’s far-right Otzma Yehudit party: a single article Abu Shehadeh published on October 8, 2023.

National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir arrives for a hearing on a request to disqualify Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh at the Central Elections Committee at the Knesset in Jerusalem, September 23, 2026. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)
National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir arrives for a hearing on a request to disqualify Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh at the Central Elections Committee at the Knesset in Jerusalem, September 23, 2026. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

In the article, Abu Shehadeh offered an initial reading of the unfolding events and their possible political consequences, calling it “a significant historical event in military, political, and strategic terms” whose “implications, consequences, and results will become apparent once the dust settles.” Part of this significance, he argued, was how the attacks revealed that “Israel and its intelligence services are human beings like us; they don’t know everything. Furthermore, it is possible to prevent them from infiltrating our countries, parties, and political movements … if small, besieged Gaza can do this, then others can do it more effectively and simply.”

For Baharav-Miara, the fact that Abu Shehadeh did not condemn the October 7 attack in the article, as well as his observation that “others can do” what Gaza did to prevent Israeli intelligence penetration, could constitute support for armed struggle. Abu Shehadeh rejected that interpretation, pointing to other statements in which he condemned the killing of civilians and expressed his opposition to political violence. 

The significance of the attorney general’s position, attorney Sawsan Zaher argued, lies partly in how far it deviates from the court’s existing standard for disqualification. “Until today, the Supreme Court has maintained that one statement is not enough,” she told +972 Magazine. “There needs to be a substantial body of evidence –– several articles or statements — showing that support for armed struggle is the central objective of a candidate’s political activity. This is not present in Sami’s case.” 

Yet Zaher said the attorney general’s position was widely understood as a signal that Abu Shehadeh’s disqualification could survive judicial review. “In practice, she gave the Supreme Court a green light, not only the Elections Committee,” Zaher explained. 

Another unusual intervention came from Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg, who chairs the Central Elections Committee. The judge personally voted to disqualify Abu Shehadeh, openly acknowledging that he was departing from the convention under which committee chairs abstain from disqualification votes in order to preserve their neutrality. 

Perhaps most concerning has been the breadth of the political consensus. Support for excluding Abu Shehadeh stretches from Otzma Yehudit and the Israeli far-right across the governing coalition and well into the Zionist opposition — including the Democrats, led by Yair Golan, despite the party’s efforts to court Palestinian voters.

Likud MK Tally Gotliv shouts at Joint List chairman Youssef Jabareen following a hearing on a request to disqualify the candidacy of Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh at the Central Elections Committee, at the Knesset in Jerusalem, September 23, 2026. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)
Likud MK Tally Gotliv shouts at Joint List chairman Youssef Jabareen following a hearing on a request to disqualify the candidacy of Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh at the Central Elections Committee, at the Knesset in Jerusalem, September 23, 2026. (Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

Writing about the disqualification decisions, Hadeel Abu Saleh — an attorney at the Haifa-based legal center Adalah — pointed to a glaring contradiction in the Elections Committee proceedings. Otzma Yehudit and Religious Zionism were also facing disqualification attempts before the committee, on the grounds of inciting racism and undermining democracy. Yet while Abu Shehadeh’s article was deemed sufficient to support his disqualification, she noted, the vast evidence presented against Otzma Yehudit and Religious Zionism was found insufficient to bar those parties. 

“This is the heart of the discrimination claim: In one case, a single article subject to interpretation may suffice to deny the right to be elected; in the other case, a large body of evidence is insufficient,” she wrote, describing the disparity as “apartheid in the right to be elected.”

Click here to read more: Palestinian MKs in Israel have long faced election bans. This time is different

No comments:

Post a Comment

Genocide ruling against Myanmar welcome but it highlights good and bad of international law

  Alex Cunningham Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu, Joseph Kony. All three men stand accused of slaughtering innocent civilians, abducting...