Tuesday, November 17, 2026

An ICJ victory for The Gambia will not, by itself, deliver justice for the Rohingya

 

The ICJ is expected to deliver its final ruling in the Rohingya genocide case this week, but whether the judgment brings meaningful justice to victims will depend on what happens after the verdict

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is expected to deliver its final judgment on November 19 in a landmark case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar over allegations of genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority.

The ruling, seven years after the case was filed in 2019, could mark a significant milestone in the Rohingya’s long struggle for justice. But a judgment holding Myanmar responsible under international law would not necessarily translate into meaningful remedies for victims.

That will depend not only on whether Myanmar’s rulers comply with the court’s orders, but also on the willingness of the international community to exert pressure to ensure they are implemented.

The ICJ will determine Myanmar’s responsibility as a state, rather than the individual criminal liability of its military leaders. The Gambia is not asking the court to imprison Min Aung Hlaing or other senior military officials. Instead, it is seeking a determination of whether Myanmar violated its obligations under the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, to which it is a party.

Under international law, even large-scale killings do not automatically constitute genocide. To establish guilt, The Gambia must demonstrate that the Myanmar military acted with the specific intent to destroy the Rohingya, in whole or in part, as an ethnic or religious group.

The Gambia has argued that the scale, systematic nature, and brutality of the military’s operations, together with evidence of hate speech, demonstrate genocidal intent.

Myanmar has maintained that its military operations were aimed at combating terrorism and that genocidal intent has not been established.

If the ICJ finds Myanmar in breach of the Genocide Convention, the precise violations identified and the remedies ordered will be critical.

The Gambia has sought measures including an end to violations, accountability for perpetrators, conditions allowing displaced Rohingya to return safely, restitution of lost property, and compensation for victims.

The judgment will clarify which remedies the court orders, although questions concerning the amount of compensation could be addressed in subsequent proceedings.

A binding judgment, but difficult to enforce

An ICJ judgment is not merely advisory. Under Article 59 of the court’s Statute, it is legally binding on the parties to the case. Article 60 makes the judgment final and without appeal.

Article 94(1) of the United Nations (UN) Charter also requires UN member states to comply with ICJ decisions in cases to which they are parties, but the court has no police force or independent enforcement mechanism to compel compliance.

If Myanmar refuses to implement the judgment, The Gambia could bring the matter before the UN Security Council. Under Article 94(2) of the UN Charter, the council may make recommendations or decide on measures to give effect to the ruling.

Crucially, however, the provision does not require the Security Council to act. Any enforcement measures would ultimately depend on political decisions by its members.

The limitations of this system were illustrated by the case brought by Nicaragua against the United States.

In 1986, the ICJ ruled against Washington over its actions in Nicaragua. When the United States failed to comply, Nicaragua turned to the Security Council, but Washington vetoed a draft resolution calling for compliance with the judgment.

In Myanmar’s case, the positions of China and Russia, both permanent members of the Security Council, could prove decisive.

Substantive Security Council resolutions require at least nine votes from the council’s 15 members and must not be vetoed by any of its five permanent members.

China and Russia jointly vetoed a draft resolution on Myanmar in 2007. However, both abstained rather than using their vetoes when the council adopted Resolution 2669 in December 2022, calling for an end to violence across Myanmar and the release of arbitrarily detained prisoners.

It would therefore be wrong to assume that Beijing and Moscow will automatically block every Security Council measure concerning Myanmar.

Nevertheless, the extent to which the council could act to enforce an ICJ judgment would depend heavily on the measures proposed and how they align with the strategic interests of major powers. Even if Security Council action proves impossible, other avenues for pursuing accountability would remain available.

The UN General Assembly could mobilise political support for compliance, while individual governments could impose sanctions under their domestic laws, apply diplomatic pressure, or support legal proceedings in other jurisdictions.

Whether such measures would be sufficient to compel Myanmar to comply, however, remains uncertain.
Justice beyond the ICJ ruling

Alongside the ICJ proceedings, separate legal efforts are underway to hold individual Myanmar military leaders accountable for crimes committed against the Rohingya.

The International Criminal Court (ICC) is separately investigating alleged crimes against the Rohingya that fall within its jurisdiction, including crimes involving their forced displacement into Bangladesh. In November 2024, its prosecutor requested an arrest warrant for Min Aung Hlaing for alleged crimes against humanity of deportation and persecution.

Efforts are also underway to pursue accountability through domestic courts in other countries. 

These proceedings are legally distinct from the ICJ case. A finding that Myanmar bears state responsibility for genocide would not automatically establish the criminal guilt of individual military commanders.

Each criminal case would still require courts to establish jurisdiction, examine the evidence and determine the responsibility of the accused under the applicable legal standards.

Nevertheless, the ICJ’s assessment of genocidal intent, its evaluation of the evidence and its findings on Myanmar’s responsibility could become important legal references in other proceedings.

The implications of the ruling could also extend beyond Myanmar’s current military leadership.

Under international law, a state’s obligations do not disappear simply because its rulers change. Any future government in Myanmar would inherit the country’s continuing legal obligations, including any binding remedies ordered by the ICJ.

This means that even a future political transition would not absolve Myanmar of responsibility for addressing violations established by the court.

For the Rohingya, however, justice cannot be measured solely by the outcome of a court case.

Meaningful justice would require conditions allowing refugees to return home safely, the restoration of their fundamental rights, remedies for the lives and property they have lost, and an end to the discrimination and persecution they have endured.

These are the changes that would make a tangible difference to their daily lives.

The November 19 judgment may establish the extent of Myanmar’s legal responsibility under the Genocide Convention. But, whether it delivers justice to the Rohingya will ultimately be measured by what follows: whether Myanmar complies with the ruling and whether the international community can generate sufficient pressure to ensure that it does.
---------------------------------
Kyaw Lwin is a lawyer, legal scholar and human rights researcher. He holds a master’s degree in human rights from Mahidol University in Thailand and a master’s degree in public policy from Chiang Mai University. He is currently conducting research at the University of Melbourne in Australia.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Rohingya Genocide Case at the ICJ: International Justice at a Crossroad

Each possible outcome of the case has different legal consequences and implications for survivors. But none would erase what was inflicted o...