Friday, November 20, 2026

Did Plato Really Say That Democracy Selects the "Best Liar"? - by Habib Siddiqui

 Did Plato Really Say That Democracy Selects the "Best Liar"?

It is often claimed that the ancient Greek philosopher Plato—student of Socrates and author of The Republic—famously said, "Democracy never selects the best leader; it selects the best liar." Is there any truth to this attribution?
Based on Plato’s surviving works, this exact quotation never appears anywhere in his writings. While the sentiment loosely summarizes his critique of Athenian democracy, the punchy phrasing itself is a modern internet aphorism popularized on social media.
Even though the wording is fabricated, the underlying idea genuinely reflects arguments Plato made through Socrates in The Republic and Gorgias:
1. The Ship of State (The Republic, Book VI, 488a–489a)
Plato compared a democracy to a ship where untrained sailors argue over who should steer while ignoring the skilled navigator—arguing that elections reward charismatic orators and demagogues who flatter the public rather than those with true wisdom or statecraft:
"Imagine then a fleet or a ship in which there is a captain who is taller and stronger than any of the crew, but he is a little deaf and has a similar infirmity in sight, and his knowledge of navigation is not much better. The sailors are quarrelling with one another about the steering—every one is of opinion that he has a right to steer, though he has never learned the art of navigation... They have no notion that the true pilot must pay attention to the year and seasons and sky and stars and winds, and whatever else belongs to his art, if he intends to be really qualified for the command of a ship, and that he must and will be the steerer, whether other people like or not."
— Translated by Benjamin Jowett
2. The Doctor vs. The Pastry Chef (Gorgias, 464d–465a & 521e)
Plato compared a true statesman to a doctor and a democratic politician to a pastry chef, illustrating how voters often prefer someone who feeds them pleasant illusions over someone who prescribes bitter truths:
"I shall be tried just as a physician would be tried in a court of little boys at the indictment of the cook. Consider what a plea a man like me could make if caught in such a predicament... 'Boys, this man has done you all a great deal of mischief; he is the death of the youngest of you with his cutting and burning, and drives you to despair with his starving and choking, giving you the bitterest draughts and compelling you to hunger and thirst; not like me, who used to feast you on abundance of sweets of every kind!'"
— Translated by W.R.M. Lamb
3. How Demagogues Corrupt Democracy (The Republic, Book VIII, 560c & 565e)
Describing how democratic societies fall prey to manipulative leaders, Plato warned that empty rhetoric and falsehoods eventually crowd out genuine wisdom:
"And these [truths] they drive out and purge away... and having thus emptied and swept clean the soul of him who is now in their power... they proceed to bring back insolence and anarchy and waste and impudence in bright array... calling insolence breeding, and anarchy liberty, and waste magnificence, and impudence courage."
— Translated by Benjamin Jowett
In Summary
Plato warned that excessive freedom and populist rhetoric allow manipulative leaders—filled with "false and braggart words"—to exploit public emotions and eventually turn a democracy into tyranny. While he never uttered the viral "best liar" line, he did write a genuinely famous warning on leadership in The Republic (Book I, 347c):
"The heaviest penalty for declining to rule is to be ruled by someone inferior to yourself."

No comments:

Post a Comment

Statement by the Secretary-General on the International Court of Justice Judgment in “The Gambia v. Myanmar”

  Press Release Statement by the Secretary-General on the International Court of Justice Judgment in “The Gambia v. Myanmar” 19 November 202...